Midwest Modesty is an album by Before Their Eyes, released in 2016. The album is a Limited Edition rock LP.

• 1 It's Dark Inside With You
• 2 The Positive And The Negative Of Being Alone
• 3 We Won't Make The Same Mistake Again
• 4 How It Feels To Be Defeated
• 5 Anything's Possible In New Jersey
• 6 Midwest Modesty
• 7 A Home With No Ceilings
• 8 We Destroyed All The Evidence
• 9 Noise
• 10 Adam Was A Cool Dude